Research & Synthesis
Researching is gathering data from credible, reliable, and relevant sources. After data is gathered, it must be synthesized, or merged, into a coherent whole. All sources from which data is gathered must be acknowledged, or cited.
Choosing Appropriate Sources |
Relevant sources are those that are related to the subject matter.
NOT RELEVANT: Asian Tigers, African Lions, a nonfiction book about big cats in the wild
RELEVANT: The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Cat Breeds, a nonfiction book about breeds of pet cats.
Credible and reliable sources are those that are believable and trustworthy.
NOT A GOOD SOURCE:
advertisement for a brand of "healthy" cat food
NOT A GOOD SOURCE: website with popular cat videos that people have posted of their pets eating their favorite foods
GOOD SOURCE: website with the
URL www.thecatnetwork.org, a nonprofit organization dedicated to educating people about how to care for pet cats
Primary vs. Secondary Sources |
A
primary source provides first-hand information about a topic.
RESEARCH TOPIC: Civil Rights Movement
primary source: an interview with someone who lived through and experienced the Civil Rights Movement
RESEARCH TOPIC: E.E. Cummings, an American poet
primary source: The actual poems that E.E. Cummings wrote
A
secondary source provides second-hand information about a topic.
RESEARCH TOPIC: Civil Rights Movement
secondary source: A chapter about the Civil Rights Movement in a school textbook
RESEARCH TOPIC: E.E. Cummings, an American poet
secondary source: A biography of E.E. Cummings, published on a website about famous American poets
Avoiding Sources with Faulty Reasoning |
Bandwagon Appeal: A logical fallacy based on the faulty reasoning that one should accept an idea or argument because others do.
This statement provides no real data about the dependability of the trucks. It only states that 9 out of 10 Americans — people like you — think that they are dependable, suggesting that YOU should think so, too.
Repetition: A logical fallacy based on the idea that if a statement is
repeated over and over again,
even without supporting evidence, it must be true.
CANDIDATE 1: Texas schools are the highest ranked schools in the nation.
DEBATE MODERATOR: I do believe that Massachusetts has the highest ranked schools, based on most objective ranking systems.
CANDIDATE 1: That's ridiculous. Texas schools are number 1 in the nation.
CANDIDATE 2: (interrupting) Excuse me, but on the most recent U.S. News and World Report rankings, Texas was Number 37. That's one reason why we need to invest more in our public education system.
CANDIDATE 1: That's simply not accurate. Texas has the best public schools in the nation!
CANDIDATE 2: (stops arguing)
DEBATE MODERATOR: Moving on to our next topic . . .
Candidate 1 never provides supporting evidence for his or her statement about Texas school ranking. Instead, he or she just keeps repeating the assertion until others stop arguing.
Loaded Language: A logical fallacy based on the use of language that appeals to emotions rather than to reason.
While providing no supporting evidence for his or her claims, the writer or speaker uses words that are strongly negative in order to evoke a negative reaction towards climate change theories in his or her audience.
BEWARE of sources with strongly emotive words and no supporting evidence!
Circular Reasoning: A logical fallacy in which a conclusion is based on a premise that was itself based on the same conclusion.
A: Fluoride should continue to be put into municipal water supplies.
B: Fluoride is good for people's dental health.
B: Fluoride is good for people's dental health because . . .
A: We've been putting fluoride into municipal water supplies for years, so it must be good!
❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋ ❋
It is important to use a variety of credible, reliable, and relevant sources, free of flawed reasoning and biases, when researching topics you are writing about. After gathering information from your sources, you must synthesize the information from different sources into a coherent piece of writing of your own. Go to the next page to see an example of synthesizing data from a variety of sources. |